Some people do not like to hear of people removing face paint or "damaging" a doll's original features. I think these people think of the original dolls as "art" and they feel as though somebody is damaging "art". In reality, if something is mass produced then it is not truly a piece of art (in the true sense of the word). Although I see many poorly done OOAK dolls, people who probably shouldn't repaint, reroot, or restyle anything ... I also see a lot of beautiful dolls. The fact of the matter is we are all free to do whatever we choose. If you are a collector who likes to keep their doll original the just think, the more people who turn that doll into an OOAK the less there will be in original condition and perhaps she will become harder to find.
Being one who missed out on the Silkstone Lingerie #1 and #2 I always remember all the OOAK dolls I used to see done out of them and the dolls in good condition are commanding around $250 now. I truly wonder if any people regret transforming their Silkstones now.
Randall
You've raised good points that I've responded to in your letter: ----- Original Message ----- From: Choic4guys@aol.com To: candichat@dolls.de Sent: Wednesday, April 02, 2003 11:28 AM Subject: Re: Veronique & Adele/doll jointing
Some people do not like to hear of people removing face paint or
"damaging" a
doll's original features. I think these people think of the original dolls
as
"art" and they feel as though somebody is damaging "art".
I've thought about this and have wondered would an art collector go to the trouble of taking any original art work and remove part of the paint on the canvas to add their touches to the art? If the piece is one-of-a-kind, and at any price, no, I highly doubt a person would buy that art only to reinterpret that artist's work. Why bother buying the art if you don't like the artist's work?
In reality, if something is mass produced then it is not truly a piece of
art
(in the true sense of the word).
Here may be what separates an artist's original piece's value from reproduction numbers. What does one consider mass produced? I don't know what is the official number for dolls to be considered mass produced. Also, there is definitely a difference from a doll collector and a doll makeover artist and their purposes for buying a doll.
There was a first fashion doll convention in Dallas recently and I understand Jim Faraone was going to be there to judge the makeover categories. Does anyone know what the rules and standards for judging the makeover dolls were?
If you are a collector who likes to keep their doll original the just think, the more people who turn that doll into an OOAK
the
less there will be in original condition and perhaps she will become
harder
to find.
Oh! I can hope so!!!
I cringe to think there are people who repaint Tonner's Sydneys, but I do like to see what makeover artists do with Genes. I like the first 4 Genes and the original concept, but find the blue eyes boring afterwards. So eventually, the dolls seem almost like blank canvases to me, waiting for new ideas to be painted. Also, there are so many blue-eyed Genes, that I'm not worried about a shortage. And, too, Genes without costumes sell for about $30. That's a lot more affordable to repaint than a Sydney or a CED--unless you're really, really good at repainting.
Being one who missed out on the Silkstone Lingerie #1 and #2 I always remember all the OOAK dolls I used to see done out of them and the dolls
in
good condition are commanding around $250 now. I truly wonder if any
people
regret transforming their Silkstones now.
I would wonder, too, Randall. I would wonder, too. Pat
When people 1st got into redoing barbie a number of years ago ...I was going to get a bunch of repaints as the ones I saw were so beautiful...however the prices were out of this world too. I did buy a really neat one of an AA doll with the short fuzzy hair & she was so beautifully done in a tropical print dress with purple shoes & purse & there was a hat & jewelry too...I bought her t a lower price at the end of a doll show...long ago. Thinking all redone dolls just had to be as beautiful as the ones I'd been seen, I sent away for one, sight unseen , by a person highly recommended to me by another person who assured me this ones work was just amazing. What I got was a doll with eyelashes inserted so thickly it looked like caterpillars laying on the eyelids, an overly done makeup job , stiff ugly hairdo & an outfit with buttons way too big for the doll's size & held on with huge snaps ...the only thing good I can say is that the price was right. Pat H.